Lovecraft's prose might have been sufficient back then, but in today's writing landscape you've got to get rid of any inclination to use adverbs. And most people like it when sentences are succinct, short and simple, and you get the point across in fewer words. Which, unfortunately, is not Lovecraft.
Then again, I guess I should be proud that the internet thinks I write like one of my literary idols. And don't get me wrong, I am... to an extent. But I think this is telling me I need to work on my writing a bit more, make it more sharp. In the meantime I'm going to play around with this website and see what other great literary figures my writing can dare to be compared.
Edit: I've been playing around with the website and it seems like the author I get compared to the most is Stephen King. Hmm... I'm a little happier about that.